Slice of Heaven Custom Cakes Sarasota

We specialize in Hand Crafted Custom Cakes for all types of life's events.

If it's a custom cake you are seeking, we are one of the best with 20 years experience.

Not your traditional bakery, but a highly specialized business focused on event cakes.

  From a simple gathering to major life events, we have done them all.


Sarasota's Best Handcrafted Cakes

Custom cakes require min 5 to 7 day advance order. Don't wait till last minute.

Absolute minimum 24 hour advance for very simple designs (NO SAME DAY CAKES HERE)

We typically sell out the weekend by Tuesday, sometimes sooner.  Plan early.

Once we reach our production goals we no longer can take orders for that weekend.  Handcrafted cake orders must be complete with deposit prior cut off to be considered booked.

Email Us. or call 341-0038 to leave a voice message for the best cakes in Sarasota.  We will respond timely, but existing cake orders are priority and depending on work load responses can be delayed. 

Kids  (13)
carved (326)

5632 Palmer Blvd

Sarasota, Fl 34232



Monday 10am - 2pm

Tuesday thru Friday 10am - 5pm

Saturday 10am - 2pm

Sunday Closed

Phone: 941-341-0038

Any Theme or Occasion Imaginable

Sign Up for our Email List

Great incentives and announce events. Click the (email sign up link) in upper right tool bar.

Be sure to share your cake pictures and experience with the world on Trip Advisor

Custom cakes require minimum of 5-7 days advance notice.   Book early!

Tuesday by 5:00 pm is cut off for weekend custom work....plan ahead.

Check out over 8000 pictures in the galleries

Sarasota’s premier custom cake bakery since 1997! (We have been handcrafting thousands of custom cake designs for over 18 years.) We are passionate and proud to offer some of the best tasting, handcrafted, and innovative cake designs in the area. Privately operated with focus of one cake at a time, earning your business from the first cake through years of life's celebrations. 

A Slice of Heaven can embrace your inspirations, theme, motif, and colors to create the unique showpiece. We offer pro quality custom inspired cakes with smooth buttercream, that's right, not one cake has ever been covered in fondant. Super moist cake, awesome fillings, clean designs and professional quality finish.

Our custom cakes can be made in every theme imaginable. Our cakes are not fondant but smooth butter cream with taste, flavor, and moistness that is unmatched on West Coast Florida. 18 years and thousands of wedding cakes we are masters of butter cream.Our product is often seen at and recommended by many fine venues from Tampa to Boca Grande.  From the simplest dinner cake, baby shower, children's birthday, to a wedding or huge event for 500. We are dedicated to making an awesome product with your inspirations. Call the pros! We will do whatever it takes to make you a client for life!

How to Order / Get Quote

Select a picture (right click to copy) from our galleries or elsewhere..Or not!

Select a theme, motif, and color palette.

Identify a budget range and amount of servings.  (very importantWe will quickly make design suggestions that are relative the cost and offer alternative ways to embrace the same theme at your price point.

Select a cake flavor and filling from the "Flavors and Fillings Tab"

Choose a cake size and dimension. "Cake Pricing Tab"

Email us a picture of the design and information requested above for a reply quote (   Not sure?  Call us.. speak to a cake professional.

DECORATORS CHOICE? Tell us the theme and budget and we will take all the work out of designing a great cake. Let the Pros run with it!  (Most cost effective and impressive)

When to Order?

(Minimum 5-7 day advance order for custom work)  Large events several weeks to months.

Tuesday  5:00 pm is the cut off for custom cake orders for that weekend.  Occasionally we can do simple cakes in a day or two notice depending on work load.

Absolute minimum 24 hour advance for very simple designs (NO SAME DAY CAKES HERE)

If you are ready to make deposit then we urge you to book asap.

Thoughts to consider when selecting a cake style!

Artwork is additional and can substantially add to the base cost of a cake.

Multi tier stacked cakes are substantially more expensive than single tier cakes.  $190+

3 Dimensional items are very time consuming and add considerable cost  (consider supplying non edible figurines or toys).  

Sculpted bottles, purses, and just about any items that can be represented with a carved style cake begin at $140+ but typically are $250-600 range. 

Tilted or mad hatter style cakes begin at $6.00 per serving or at $145+ 

Multi tier wedding cake full custom designs begin at $4.75 per portion.

Identifying a budget for the event is important and allows us to immediately make design recommendations based on your price point.

Event Cake Cancellation / Refund Policy

Be VERY CLEAR that all deposited cake orders are subject to the loss of 25% of total amount in the event of cancellation for ANY reason.

50% deposit required for cakes $75 and over

Cancellation 72 hours or more: 25% of total invoice is retained.

Cancellation 71 to 49 hours: 50% of total invoice is retained.

Cancellation 48-25 hours: 75% of total invoice retained.

Cancellation 24 hours or less: 100% of total invoice retained.

In the event the cake date, design, or size changes once deposit or payment is made, we reserve the right to assess fees as necessary.  Costs include time incurred in artwork, ordering, consultation, and planning @ rate of $60 per hour.  At our discretion, we reserve the right to provide refund in form of "store credit" only and not provide a cash refund.  

Full payment required for any delivered cakes.

Email if the best way to cancel an order. (

This policy does not apply to wedding cake contracts, see "wedding info" page in website.